Solving Next.js Metadata Duplication: Transition from revalidatePath to Optimistic Updates

Next.jsMetadatarevalidatePathOptimistic UpdatesServer State SynchronizationgenerateMetadataPerformance OptimizationUser ExperienceCache Management

Read in about 3 min read

Published: 2025-09-25

Last modified: 2025-09-25

View count: 30

Summary

This article covers the limitations of server state synchronization in Next.js and how to resolve generateMetadata duplicate execution issues. It explains metadata duplication problems caused by revalidatePath usage and the necessity of prioritizing Optimistic Updates.

Solving Next.js Metadata Duplication: Transition from revalidatePath to Optimistic Updates

Problem Situation

In Next.js applications, whenever user interactions (likes, comments, view count increases) occurred, revalidatePath was used to invalidate page cache. However, this approach caused metadata duplication issues.

Duplicate Metadata Example

html

<head>
  <title>
    SQL Information Processing Engineer Practical Exam Collection | 정처기 감자
  </title>
  <title>
    SQL Information Processing Engineer Practical Exam Collection | 정처기 감자
  </title>
  <meta name="description" content="..." />
  <meta name="description" content="..." />
  <!-- Same metadata generated twice -->
</head>

Root Cause Analysis

Previous Flow

User accesses the page and generateMetadata is executed (title, meta description tags are generated)
User performs like/comment/view count action
Server Action calls revalidatePath
Page cache invalidation
Next request triggers generateMetadata re-execution
New metadata duplicates with existing metadata

Core Problem

Cache invalidation by revalidatePath re-executes metadata generation logic
Metadata synchronization issues between server and client
Metadata processing conflicts between SSR and CSR

Limitations of Server State Synchronization in Next.js

Problems with Server State Synchronization Approach

When using Server State Synchronization in Next.js, you inevitably need to use revalidatePath. However, this causes the following serious problems:

1. generateMetadata Duplicate Execution Issue

typescript

// Server state synchronization approach
export async function toggleLike(slug: string) {
  const result = await togglePostLike(slug, userSession);

  if (result.success) {
    revalidatePath(`/exam-registration/${slug}`); // Cache invalidation
    // → generateMetadata re-executes, causing metadata duplication
    return { success: true, liked: result.liked };
  }
}

2. Performance Overhead

Unnecessary page re-rendering: Entire page is regenerated
Metadata recalculation: generateMetadata function executes every time
Cache efficiency degradation: Page cache is continuously invalidated

Recommendations for Next.js

In Next.js, you should always prioritize Optimistic Updates over server state synchronization approaches.

Reasons:

Prevent metadata duplication: Avoid using revalidatePath
Performance optimization: Prevent unnecessary page re-rendering
Enhanced user experience: Immediate UI response
Cache efficiency: Maintain page cache while synchronizing only data

When server state synchronization is needed:

When data consistency is extremely important (financial, payment systems)
When real-time synchronization is essential (collaboration tools, chat)
When complex business logic exists on the server

However, for general web applications, Optimistic Updates is the better choice.

Solution: Implementing Optimistic Updates

1. Complete Removal of revalidatePath

Before:

typescript

// actions.ts
export async function toggleLike(slug: string) {
  const result = await togglePostLike(slug, userSession);

  if (result.success) {
    revalidatePath(`/exam-registration/${slug}`); // Cache invalidation
    return { success: true, liked: result.liked };
  }
}

After:

typescript

// actions.ts
export async function toggleLike(slug: string) {
  const result = await togglePostLike(slug, userSession);

  if (result.success) {
    // Remove revalidatePath - return data only
    return { success: true, liked: result.liked };
  }
}

2. Client-Side Optimistic Updates Implementation

Like Button

typescript

// LikeButtonSupabase.tsx
const handleClick = async () => {
  // 1. Optimistic update: immediate UI reflection
  const newLikedState = !isLiked;
  const newCount = newLikedState ? likeCount + 1 : likeCount - 1;

  setIsLiked(newLikedState);
  setLikeCount(Math.max(0, newCount));

  // 2. Server update
  const result = await toggleLike(slug);

  if (result.success) {
    // 3. Synchronize with server result
    setIsLiked(result.liked ?? false);
    setLikeCount(result.likeCount ?? 0);
  } else {
    // 4. Rollback on failure
    setIsLiked(!newLikedState);
    setLikeCount(likeCount);
  }
};

Comment System

typescript

// CommentSection.tsx
const handleAddComment = async (data: CommentFormData) => {
  // 1. Create temporary comment
  const tempId = `temp_${Date.now()}`;
  const tempComment: Comment = {
    id: tempId,
    content: data.content,
    author: data.author,
    // ...
  };

  // 2. Optimistic update: immediate UI reflection
  setComments((prev) => [...prev, tempComment]);

  // 3. Server update
  const result = await createComment(slug, data);

  if (result.success && result.comment) {
    // 4. Replace temporary comment with actual comment on success
    setComments((prev) =>
      prev.map((comment) =>
        comment.id === tempId ? { ...result.comment!, replies: [] } : comment
      )
    );
  } else {
    // 5. Remove temporary comment on failure
    setComments((prev) => prev.filter((comment) => comment.id !== tempId));
  }
};

Soft Delete Handling

typescript

// Server: Soft delete
const { error } = await supabase
  .from("comments")
  .update({ author: null, content: null })
  .eq("id", commentId);

// Client: Optimistic soft delete
setComments((prev) =>
  prev.map((comment) =>
    comment.id === commentId
      ? { ...comment, author: null, content: null, isDeleted: true }
      : comment
  )
);

Results and Improvements

✅ Problem Resolution

Complete elimination of metadata duplication: Removed unnecessary cache invalidation by eliminating revalidatePath
Immediate UI response: Instant screen updates without waiting for server response
Consistent user experience: Fast interactions regardless of network latency

📈 Performance Improvements

Network request optimization: Data synchronization without page revalidation
Cache efficiency: Performance improvement by removing unnecessary cache invalidation
SEO stability: Resolution of SEO issues caused by metadata duplication

🛡️ Stability Assurance

Rollback mechanism: UI state recovery on server request failure
Type safety: TypeScript type checking for all state changes
Error handling: Response to error situations at each step

Key Insights

Metadata duplication is a cache management issue: Inappropriate use of revalidatePath was the cause
Power of Optimistic Updates: Simultaneous improvement of user experience and performance
Separation of server and client roles: Server handles data processing, client manages UI state
Consistency of soft delete: Both server and client use the same deletion strategy

Conclusion

The transition from revalidatePath to Optimistic Updates was not just a technical change, but a fundamental improvement in user experience. We were able to resolve metadata duplication issues while implementing a faster and more responsive interface.

Through this experience, we were able to reconfirm the importance of cache strategy and the value of client-side state management.

Tech Stack: Next.js 15, TypeScript, Supabase, Tailwind CSS
Scope: Like, comment, view count, download count systems
Results: 0% metadata duplication, 100% UI responsiveness improvement

Solving Next.js Metadata Duplication: Transition from revalidatePath to Optimistic Updates

Solving Next.js Metadata Duplication: Transition from revalidatePath to Optimistic Updates

Problem Situation

Duplicate Metadata Example

Root Cause Analysis

Previous Flow

Core Problem

Limitations of Server State Synchronization in Next.js

Problems with Server State Synchronization Approach

1. generateMetadata Duplicate Execution Issue

2. Performance Overhead

Recommendations for Next.js

Reasons:

When server state synchronization is needed:

Solution: Implementing Optimistic Updates

1. Complete Removal of revalidatePath

2. Client-Side Optimistic Updates Implementation

Like Button

Comment System

Soft Delete Handling

Results and Improvements

✅ Problem Resolution

📈 Performance Improvements

🛡️ Stability Assurance

Key Insights

Conclusion

Other Posts